In abandoning God, our society has also abandoned a number of ideas, the absence of which has helped hollow it out. If God provides nothing else, he provides a purpose for life and a standard by which we might evaluate a good life. In his absence, life has no necessary purpose beyond the fact we have to live it; that being the case it is a good idea to live it as comfortably as we can. How fortunate (and not at all coincidental) that we have evolved a system – capitalism – which can provide whatever we want – as long as we can afford it. Of the buying and selling things there is no end; everything, in the end is for sale; everything has a price – even our values. Modern liberalism is, it is tempting to say, based on nothing more elevated than satisfying the demands of our own egos. Ultimately it leads to a form of democracy in which the fact that a majority want something means they get it, even if that something is something sold to them on a false prospectus; the majority wanted it, they get what they wanted. Parliamentary/Representative democracy was designed to put some safeguards against majoritarian tyranny; but why should the majority not simply get what it wants? Who cares about what the losers wanted? They lost. This is not, one suspects, a situation in which democracy as we have known it can sustain itself for very much longer. Here in the UK we see the chasm between the two sides of the argument on the ‘Brexit’ referendum grow no narrower, and when Mr Trump loses the American Presidential election, his supporters will be loud in proclaimed he was robbed; they will no doubt get louder as it becomes clear that Mrs Clinton has no idea of how to put things right.
Our new Prime Minister, Mrs May, has been talking about the need for Government to intervene to moderate the effects of the ‘market’. That sounds a splendid idea – but mainly to those not old enough to recall what it used to be like when British Governments thought they could control prices and incomes with a ‘policy’; of course they couldn’t. But nonetheless, in an economic situation in which the majority feel they are getting worse off, and where they can see a minority getting obscenely better off, calls for such intervention are going to be popular; that, after all, is where such calls came from back in the 1920s and 1930s. But how you create a ‘responsible’ capitalism with a social conscience in a system where shared values are few, and where what matters is how much money you can make and how much you can consume with it, is a moot point.
The values which used to underpin such ideas were based on a Christian understanding of society. They wee certainly imperfectly implemented, but they were also part of the glue which created a society rather than a set of atomised individuals competing for resources. People had a value in themselves, they were made in the image of God. The meaning of our lives was not something to be created from abstract notions of personal worth, but were rather givens to be discovered and explored through our Christian faith; we were stewards, not owners of the planet and its resources. Communities were secular versions of the church community, united by common values and assumptions; no man was truly an island.
If, as many of us would assert, we are living in a time of crisis, then perhaps the greatest cause of this is the loss of the sense of God, of anything beyond our own mundane imaginings and our monstrous egos.
Indeed, and so as we go round the prickly pear, we wonder if
” This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
Not with a bang but a whimper.”
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is certainly hard to find reasons for optimism
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is that, but perhaps we should settle for avoiding the (really big) bang?
LikeLiked by 2 people
That’d do 😊
LikeLiked by 2 people
I think so, as well! 🙂
LikeLike
I think what struck me about this piece is the lack of control we really have over “the system”, be it the political system or the economic one. The idea that “it’s all going to get worse” is a temptation to believe we can do nothing about it. I’m not sure I have an answer, except perhaps to reassess the methodology of judgement. My pastor made the point in his sermon this morning that the West is living in spiritual poverty – but the Church is thriving in the rest of the world, even if she is persecuted.
LikeLiked by 2 people
A side of me wonders if the church in much of the world isn’t thriving because it is persecuted, as Cranmer’s report from Syria today,
http://archbishopcranmer.com/christian-missionaries-aleppo-crucified-beheaded/
which sounds like something from the first millennia. It’s been a long time since we held to our Faith like that. Maybe that’s why it means comparatively little to us.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Indeed, and the world cannot understand it either. They think Christians are crazy to lay down their lives rather than submit to Satan.
LikeLiked by 2 people
True, but you know, those Islamic radicals understand perfectly, which is why it happens so much. I doubt they realize that at some point we will realize that they, like their predecessors, are indeed martyrs of the faith. The world will never understand, this conflict is between believers and they are merely bystanders.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Possibly so, Neo
LikeLiked by 1 person
We are living in a self-imposed spiritual poverty at that.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I keep thinking of Jesus’ phrase in the Parable of the Sower: “the deceitfulness of riches”. I remember a talk on money I once heard at Holy Trinity. One phrase has stayed with me over the years from that talk: “money is not neutral”.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jesus had pretty clear views on money and its effects on us – none of them favourable.
LikeLike
“our own mundane imaginings”
Ill tell you what a mundane imaging is;
Its believing that everything in the book of Rev has happened already. Yes….don’t worry, the Beast and his persecuting the saints has come and gone. Uh, pass me the air spray honey, and bring me some velveeta processed cheese food. The hail and the boils and the locust have come and gone. We are just waiting for the Lord to show up again. Don’t worry, hes not coming any time soon. Hurry and get dressed honey , im going to warm up the car. The church service starts in 15 mins. Todays sermon is about how we are the true church of god and everyone else is in error. Don’t want to miss this one.
LikeLike
Bosco,I have no idea What you are on about
LikeLike
Don’t worry. Its not important.
LikeLike
Let not your heart be troubled. Your religion has added 7 more saints…..good news for the idol makers. 7 more figurines to add to the “economy of images”. 7 more saints to rule over your daily lives. Lets see….Saint Tomas More, the Butcher of London, is the patron saint of politicians. There is a saint for pre paid phone cards…forgot his name. A saint for lost items and a saint for animals. I cant wait to see what aspect of life these new saint will rule over. Life must be a bed of roses, what with all these saints taking care of every aspect of your daily life. Oh, one little catch….you have to pray to them first, otherwise they don’t help you. Yes, Jesus spoke of little else.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/pope-francis-leads-canonization-ceremony-161124426.html
LikeLike
So, when a judge carries out the State sanctioned death penalty he’s a butcher? Goodness me, you live an abattoir then!
LikeLike
Call me crazy, but being put to death for stabbing an innocent toddler and being torn apart for owning a bible are two different things. One is just punishment and the other is wickedness.
LikeLike
Both are crimes set by the State in question.
LikeLike
Back then , under catholic church rule, bibles and the reading of them were capital punishment. So its fine and dandy. It was against the law to be jewish in Germany. By catholic reasoning…well, that’s how it goes. No prob.
LikeLike
Again, a legend. It was not against the law to read the Bible. It was against the law to read the wrong translation.
LikeLike
And Bosco lends weight to why it was. They may have had a point!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Come on good brother, this is not the religion led by the holy ghost. Burning people for a translation of the bible. Time to stop making excuses for that false religion. Jesus is always there. Earnestly ask him what he thinks. Ask him to reveal himself and he will show you the truth.
LikeLike
My favorite saint, which I use on Saturday mornings is St Bibiana, the patron saint of hangovers.
LikeLike
It would seem to me that the following article explains a lot: http://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2016/10/17811/
For it is a certainty that I have sat idly by and watched the beautiful things in life get destroyed systematically. I have watched failed ideologies gain respect and the best of patriotism or capitalism as most of experience get flogged to death by rabidly furious peoples who have taken all that was given to them and demanded more. For it is a certainty that we have lost our gratitude and thankfulness for all that our democratic republic has given to us as an inheritance and all they see is that it isn’t fair; and not that they covet those who put their freedom and their unmerited gifts to far better use than they. We have free schools, libraries and safety nets for health, disability and poverty. When in history was there ever a more compassionate society created and the rights of the people protected by law to the extent that they are now? Reality is surely being distorted and we no longer are capable of actually seeing the good within anything.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I should add that there are few that are willing to defend or to preserve the communal values and civic goods that are heaped upon us. We would rather say that we can imporove upon everything which is absurd. Civil society has no perfection this side of heaven and yet our forefathers did persevere to try to give us a rather good framework to live within; though not everyone will prosper or live without some degree of suffering. What of it? To destroy that which brought more wealth, opportunity, advancement in technologies and medicine are not a given. Will we be happier without all the advantages that western society brought us? It seems that everyone wants to reinvent wheels these days instead of using them to help us get through this life a bit easier.
LikeLike