
One thing that the current situation has given some of us is time and space we lacked. Conscious as I am of those who have less of either, I haven’t wanted to blog on it. It’s all too easy to sit in a comfortable home with space, and to have time to think, and forget those who have neither and yet without whom we’d be worse off. We get pretty regular deliveries, partly because of my book-buying habit, but also other things because it’s easier than going to supermarkets, and I am struck by the quiet heroism of those who drive the white vans than keep me supplied. We used to do a good deal of clapping for NHS workers, but I sometimes feel I’d like to applaud the van drivers and the shop assistants who, literally, keep us supplied with our daily wants.
None of us has any idea when or how this will end. But if at the end of it we simply have the old normal back, I am not sure that would be progress. I’m no economist, but I can’t see how it can be right for those working in Amazon warehouses to be on low wages when Jeff Bezos is the world’s richest man. Even before the crisis it was clear that something had gone wrong with our economic and social system, and I hope we might be able to do somethings better after this – but the forces to resist it are strong ones.
AATW does not major on the climate change crisis, and even for those who, like me, think there is a crisis, some of the activities of the soi-disant “Extinction Rebellion” seem counter-productive; but that should not blind us to what is going on. We were given stewardship over the earth by God, not ownership. Pope Francis has written eloquently on this in Laudato Si, and if you take the trouble to read it, it’s pretty sensible stuff. We can’t just continue to “take” and give nothing back.
One effect of the crisis has been fewer cars on the road and fewer journeys. My other half has been working mostly from home for the last six months with no reduction on productivity, indeed quite the opposite. I know others in the same place, and life-work balance has, for some, improved. We don’t live to work, we work to live, but too often the economic system treats us as instruments not individuals. This is our modern version of what Jesus told the Pharisees about the Sabbath – and if we can claw back time and space it would be a good thing.
There are complex reasons why in the West we have a decline in births, and abortion and contraception are only two of them. We don’t have a culture of life, and one reason for that it that couples so often need two incomes to manage that having children, even for those open to it, can become a problem. How on earth did we get to this point? What is wrong with us? Again, complex answers, but it seems to me to boil down to our society forgetting why we are here. Secular society has no satisfactory answer to that fundamental question. Christianity does.
More time in prayer, more time with God, creating the silence so he can fill it, and above all, being open to his will. If we can use this crisis to do those sort of things, then other things will change too – us most of all.
Interesting article, dearest friend, and I certainly agree about the delivery drivers, quiet heroes they are, with or without Wuhan flu. But I have no problem at all with Bezos being rich, he saw an opportunity and took it, competently. He earned his wealth. And there’s this, if you took every dime he has and gave it to his employees, they’d get maybe (at most) $100 and unemployment. On the other hand, I have a major problem with him telling me what to think, and lying to me in his Washington Post.
As we have seen this year with our governments destroying small businesses and peoples\ livelihoods, causing a large rise in suicides.
Whatever we have when this ends, if it ever does (and I am doubtful that it shall) it will not be as it was before, too many things have been changed, almost none of them for the better.
And that is probably enough from me, disagreeing with you goes against my grain, so I’ll pipe down. 🙂
LikeLiked by 3 people
I agree with your first paragraph. I have no problem with rich people; it’s the best part of America; if you have the will and the energy and strength to create such a business, you should be able to profit from your creation. As long as your workers get paid a decent wage (remembering the story of the men who worked in the vineyard for a penny for the day …), I’ve got no problems or issues with that.
I disagree, however, in regard to what happens ‘after’ – I think we will return to ‘the old normal’, new businesses will start and take the place of the ones that were lost and life will go on in the normal ‘normal’.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I hope and pray that you are correct, and with a renewed vigilance for freedom.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It may do Audre, but if so, I fear for the future. As before the French and Russian revolutions, gross inequalities of wealth, where money is concentrated in too few hands, creates circumstances where revolutions happen. When money and consuming becomes your religion, society is headed to a bad place.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I can’t really see that anyone “earns” that much wealth when those he employs are not looked after. Wealth has obligations, and tax-avoidance is a means of avoiding those obligations. Are we not all poorer as a result? After all, Bezos did not build the roads his cars drive on or the houses his workers live in or the hospitals they use – but starved of his tax dollars, the infrastructure deteriorates so that what? So that he can have more money than anyone can use in several lifetimes?
It’s such abuses which fuel the opposition to capitalism. It’s like before the French and Russian revolutions. The very rich only learn too late.
LikeLiked by 1 person
We are not, we are better off because all of the things Amazon sells us for less than others would. It’s a difference between Britons and Americans. Britons tend to envy the wealthy, Americans try to emulate them, Those poor downtrodden Amazon employees make more than I ever did per hour BTW. I have no problem with that, they work hard for their income, and many of them perhaps should be paid more, but without Amazon, they’d make less, even if employed.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Could be, but that’s no excuse not to pay his taxes. Still, if it gets worse, then like others before him, he’ll find out the hard way – but so will the rest of us.
There was a reason the Lord thought the rich at risk of not getting in the Kingdom. xx
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’ve heard a lot about him but not that he has evaded paying tax. He, like all of us, I’m sure does his best to keep his tax bill down, but that’s just common sense.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“Amazon’s UK services arm paid just £14.5m ($16.1m) in UK corporate taxes in 2019 despite generating revenues of nearly £3bn in the country, according to the company’s latest accounts.”
That seems a little mean x
LikeLiked by 2 people
On the other hand, absent Amazon, we’d have more bookshops and smaller shops not squeezed out of businss by it. Maybe a few dollars on your groceries is a small price to pay for small business to survive?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe, but I used to work in a one store hardware store, on most items, if we wanted to, we could compete with the big guys, not all, nor could we have the selection, but on most it was an excuse.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am in the UK too, in Somerset. I refused to join in with the clapping for the NHS but perhaps because I am working class I have always recognised the value of the countless people who toil in poor working conditions, on low pay and without thanks or recognitiom in shops, warehouse and distribution centres to keep us fed and provided with necessities and who continue to do so largely unrecognised and unthanked. It is eay to cllimb aboard a bandwagon lauding workers in the NHS making. a quasi religion of that organisation and there are many heroes and heroines within that service but there are also many who have done very little as hospitals are left empty and appointments with GPs even for pressing health problems almost impossible to obtain. Normal is not what we have now and I am afraid that life as we knew it may never return because of the cowardice of the government and the manner in which they have terrified large numbers of the populace into believing that Covid is akin to the Black Death. There are far worse things in life than CV19 and fear of death is one of them. If I die because I have not followed government guidelines on handwashing or wearing a facemask or, dare I say it, meeting with friends in groups of more then half a dozen then so be it, I will welcome the chance to meet the Lord. Amen.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Well said. Of course the ‘push back’ you’re going to get on this is that it’s ok to endanger yourself but by not wearing the mask, you endanger others. There are far too many opinions on this – from science and politics – to know what’s right. Each person has to decide for himself.
LikeLiked by 3 people
As a Christian it’s simple. I am commanded to love my neighbour as myself. If my neighbour is happier if I wear a mask, why not?
LikeLike
I don’t believe that making the choice not to wear a face mask has anything to do with making anyone else happier. I do not think it is my duty to go along with the more and more absurd diktats surrounding Covid and the hysteria and paranoia that has been inculcated into a supine population who are being manipulated and cowed into submission by a government that has lost its way.
LikeLike
The Government, for whom I did not vote, is useless. It got in because a lot of people fell for its nonsense about Europe. We have not seen anything yet.
On covid, my view is simple. If it helps others feel safe, I am happy to do it, and I know a lot of very worried people who do feel happier.
LikeLike
I can see all that, but I think we have a duty as Christians to take care of each other, and if others are worried, then I am happy to wear a mask if it helps.
LikeLike
With money comes responsibility. With poverty comes freedom. The more money you make is inversely proportional to your actual freedom.
I was never so free than when I could put everything I owned in a $300 used Karen Ghia and drove a taxi for my daily bread. I never envied the rich for their bonds to those who supplied them their money.
I have worked at no-collar jobs, blue collar jobs and white collar jobs. I found that the middle area was a happy medium. The no-collar was fine when you are unmarried and it is just you. White collar is fine for those who like privilege and want to impress others. You need only decide how much freedom you are willing to hand over for the money you receive. There is no free lunch.
To want to attach money to those who are free from responsibility and do not earn it is preposterous. We see the hypocrisy everyday as rich little kids from college go out, rioting, burning and looting and demanding just that: they are owed because they are revolutionaries or they are a certain race etc. Life will never work like that and socialism has failed everywhere that it has been tried. It always ends with an elite ruling class and a common peasantry.
I’d go back to the 50’s American society in a heartbeat. Society as the Argentinian antipope sees it is a Marxist or Peronist nightmare.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Not sure where I suggested anything more than Catholic Social Teaching in Rerum Novarum suggests – which is a fair day’s work for a fair day’s pay. I think you’re arguing with someone else.
I see you still don’t like your Pope. Isn’t that what we Protestants do?
LikeLiked by 2 people
You are correct. I do not like Communist sympathizers who sell out the Catholic Church to the Communist party which he did in China and continues to heap praises on many Communist dictators throughout the world. There is nothing Traditionally Catholic about that.
LikeLiked by 1 person
So is he the Pope or not? I’m not understanding the RCC. I thought you accepted the Pope whom your church elected or you were a Protestant.
LikeLike
I think any Catholic must try to grapple with the issue of Bergoglio’s validity in light of his heretical statements and his worship of the pagan goddess Pachamama from the altars. We have had over 40 antipopes in our history. Are we too modern and sophisticated to have one in our own time? Let each man explain to himself how this man’s actions are to be interpreted in light of the Tradition of the Faith and the Scriptures.
The Pope is not Christ. He represents Christ. Christ is the head of the Church. If the Pope wants to alter and change the beliefs of Christ’s Church, then either the Pope is not the Pope or Christ is not the head of the Church. Let each man take stock of the situation as best they can and decide the solution that best accommodates his conscience.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I suspect Jess is a One Nation Tory, which is my preference – fix some serious areas but still leave basic freedoms in place and show respect for gradual evolution. For my part there are various matters of land, banking, and legal reform I wish to see addressed. I wish also that somehow in all of this we could get more religion in our national life and discourse – a quiet, English form. I think our souls are full of anxiety and grief. We need to hear the Shepherd’s voice.
LikeLiked by 4 people
I don’t know what I am politically, I just don’t see how huges inequalities of wealth work for the health of any society.
LikeLiked by 2 people