This page has a helpful list of biblical verses on the subject of a teachable spirit. An attitude of intellectual humility is an essential part off Christian life, not only in our ethical frameworks, but also in our engagement with science and schools of interpretation.
Virtue epistemology, a definition of knowledge pioneered by philosophers such as Zagzebski, Greco, and Sosa, holds that S knows that p when:
- p is true;
- S believes that p; and
- S’s true belief is a result of S exercising his intellectual virtues.
What sort of attitudes might one put in a list of intellectual virtues? Here are a few suggestions.
- Truth should not be silenced.
- Truth is worth hard work.
- Truth is worth risking friendships.
- One should hold the right doctrine for the right reasons.
- Expert opinion that is relevant ought to be considered (though not blindly followed).
There are many more attitudes one could add to this list. People do not consciously think of them, as a general rule, when pursuing a line of inquiry, but they are nevertheless fundamental to the way many people think (some of the time). However, as in all moral matters, observance of such principles is hindered by competing priorities, whether legitimate or illegitimate. The sin nature tempts humans to be lazy and to suppress factors that get in the way of a desired outcome. Humanity’s propensity to deceive further complicates this problem, both internally, in the context of a psychomachia, and externally, in the context of dialogue between people.
This duty to follow sound intellectual principles weighs most heavily on apologists, evangelists, and preachers of homilies and sermons. Why is it important that people should have the correct exegesis for correct exegetical reasons? The principal concern is that nothing happens in isolation. In other words, if faulty methodology or an incorrect meaning is imparted as a stage in the process of discovery, there is a possibility that this mistake could be applied to another inquiry, creating a false result.
Mistakes will be made, and no-one is perfect. For this reason, it is important to establish a culture of free discussion in which corrective recommendations can be made. The perpetuation of error is not in anyone’s interest. This core principle, which recognises mankind’s fallibility and need for reform, lies at the heart of the Christian message: Christians should remember to apply it to their study of Scripture, science, and philosophy.
Interesting, thanks.
LikeLiked by 2 people
You’re welcome.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Given the ‘truth’ of this analysis, it does beg us to evaluate attitudes and beliefs that have grown up among our nation states during the last 50 or 60 years; for these principles are not only valid for theological arguments and understanding but civilization itself depends on valid and truthful principles to be built upon. I might propose the following for some individual thought:
1) Truth may be inconvenient to certain individuals who do not wish to abandon their wish to hold to positions that exonerate them from being foolish, selfish individuals who hold as true anything that is beneficial to them personally.
2) That when the society at large has accepted the ‘snake oil salesmen’s claims’ as truthful they will end up with consequences that are far worse for the health of society than the new paradigm suggested by the narcissistic attraction of the snake oil which benefits only a few.
3) Selling untruths to a society may be a means of gaining great wealth, prestige and power if on succeeds in changing the ethical foundation of a nation state.
4) The deterioration of a society built upon lies and untruth will ultimately tear asunder both the family unit and the civilization that emerge that upheld the family unit as the foundation of civilization.
I think there are more principles to uncover here as well . . . not to mention many specific examples of our deteriorating world that has all but thrown God out of their countries as an inconvenience.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Absolutely. I like this response very much.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks. It kind of reminds me of the prophetic words of the first stanzas of Jefferson Airplane’s big hit (and the rest of the lyrics as well (look them up):
When the truth is found
To be lies
And all the joy
Within you dies
Don’t you want somebody to love
Don’t you need somebody to love
Wouldn’t you love somebody to love
You better find somebody to love, love
Sort of seems like the world treats everyone like a guest but love and joy are long gone. No wonder kids are killing each other and themselves at an alarming rate. Maybe that ‘somebody’ to love might be God? Just sayin’ . . .
LikeLiked by 3 people