I do not often consult the site’s statistics, so it was with some surprise that I noted we had over 3000 posts and more than 1000 followers, with something like 85,000 comments. Some colleagues who know of my connection with this place have queried why I bother with it, and why I spend any time here rather than on more prestigious endeavours I might devote that time to. Part of the answer is duty. I was asked to take on this site, and having said I would, I am not one to let people down. The other part is to do with the small community gathered here. Across a number of years many of you have become friends, and being of an irenic caste of mind myself, I find the somewhat eclectic nature of this community a welcome thing. The Internet can easily become either an echo chamber or a battle-ground, not least where religion is concerned; indeed, some of the intra-Catholic sniping is enough to make anyone wonder what the point of being a member of such a Church might be. Despite its occasional asperities, this site has turned into a place where Christians from a variety of backgrounds can share their experiences, and write about them without having to worry too much about trolls.
I have noticed a series of blog posts elsewhere where bloggers write about the difficulty of keeping a blog going, and I must say I have much sympathy with them. I am blessed here, in the absence of Jessica and Geoffrey Sales (who, incidentally, sends his best to all who remember him, but is busy caring for his wife), with friends who will write their pieces, and would like to thank Neo, in particular, for stepping into the breach on numerous occasions; which is not to say I am not grateful to Scoop, Nicholas, Philip Augustine and Fr Malcolm for their contributions, because I am – they all help give this place its unique flavour.
As I was looking at the statistics, I also noted that the blog began in May 2012, so by the standard of these things it has been about quite a while, and many of the early followers are no longer running blogs. That’s understandable. We all, perhaps, only have so much we want to say, and even the best and most creative amongst us repeats material. But the dialogue here, as for example about what it means to ‘be saved’, is helpful precisely because it draws in people who do not share one’s own theological predilections. Like many, my theology is largely the result of reading and discussion across the years, and there is nothing systematic about it. In some ways that’s a good thing, as it keeps the mind open, but the mind can be too open in so far as there never was a heresy that did not come to someone from their own ‘personal’ understanding of the Faith. That’s why, for me, the Church is the necessary corrective.
That last is, of course, one of the reasons why some of the intra-Catholic dialogue can be so bitter. When people know there is faith with a teaching magisterium, they understandably get upset to find that some of those within it look as though they are trying to undermine it. Much is heard about ‘mercy’ at the moment. One mercy would be an end to such things.
This blog is providing a kind of internet hostel on our pilgrim journey. We meet up and discuss our experiences and convictions as we continue our way. I for one have only just returned and am glad that I have done so. Chalcedon you are providing an extremely valuable service. Many many thanks.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Thank you Malcolm, that is much appreciated, as is your renewed presence here.
LikeLiked by 2 people
That final mercy which you long for [which is a form of peace] is not likely one which either of us will ever see in this world unless we are here for the second coming I fear. The reality of what Fulton Sheen wrote is much more probable:
“What is the attack on the Church today? It’s the world. The spirit of the world. Today we have to conform to the world or we are abandoned. Our Lord said ‘I have taken you out of the world’ and we say, ‘No, we have to win the world. To win it, you have to be one with it.’ Our Lord said, ‘I pray not for the world.’ He’s praying for the spirit of the world. And this is the easiest way to fall off the log. It’s so simple. And it’s justified by a thousand reasons. The Vatican Council said we have to go into the world. Indeed — but not to be worldly, which is quite a different matter.
“This is our attack today. There are three classes of people today: wise men, knaves, and fools. Wise men mean to do good and they do it. Knaves mean to do evil and they do it. The fools will do right or wrong depending on which is the more popular. And they are divided into white fools and black fools. The white fools would rather do right but will do wrong if it’s popular. And the black fools would rather do wrong but will do right if that’s the more popular. Now this is the situation we’re in today and this is one of the basic causes of our degeneration. We’re dying.”
LikeLiked by 2 people
Well, for myself, my motivation for writing here, is much the same, a duty owed to friends, in my case specifically you, and Jessica, even in her absence, the fact that she asked me to write here matters, and the fact that you have indeed become a close friend, as have others, also matters. I’m often reminded that Bobby Lee said, “You should always do your duty, you cannot do more, you should never do less.” If I have a life philosophy, that is probably it.
My internal theology is also a bit of a mash-up, and yes, I completely understand why it is difficult to keep blogging, as my struggles at NEO have at times illustrated. But still, we have new readers, and they came, not because of our archives, which here are valuable, but because of what we wrote today. The archives come later, we hope.
I agree with what Malcolm says above, which will surprise few, I can’t remember the last time we seriously disagreed, although often coming from opposite poles. In a few months, we will celebrate five years of AATW, it has been a wonderful time in my life, and I’m grateful to all here, and to God, for the opportunity to support in a small way, this endeavor.
LikeLiked by 5 people
Very many thanks, Neo, that is much appreciated.
LikeLiked by 2 people
You’re quite welcome.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I don’t remember when I found this blog (I think it was before I started blogging in July), and only more recently have I begun commenting. Not long ago I was considering un-following this blog, not because of a lack of good content, but because I found myself getting a little nasty in the comments section and I didn’t want to be one of “those people.” But then one of you posted something on the day I was going to un-follow, and I changed my mind. This truly is an eclectic on-line community for people of faith, and I think the debates and controversies that get stirred up in the comments sections have been good for me to read, to keep me from getting too lost in my own ideas without others to reality-check me. Thank you to all contributors (Chalcedon, Malcom, Scoop, Philip, Neo, Nicholas, even Bosco), for continuing this blog.
LikeLiked by 6 people
And thank you, Steven, for sharing that and for staying here with us. There are, indeed, seasons when things can get a little robust here, but on the whole, we manage not to strain the bonds of comradeship too often.
LikeLiked by 3 people
One of the attractions here for me, especially in the beginning, but still continuing, is the robustness of the comment streams. We all learn much in them. I still think they are one of the most important parts to this place working, sometimes more than our posts.
I’m very glad you stayed with us, Steven.
Occasionally we slip, but we really do try to keep it respectable at least, except Bosco, of course. What would we do without him?
LikeLiked by 3 people
You rang.
LikeLike
Only 21 shopping days left befor Boscomas.
The first Boscomas, the angel did say
Was to certain poor shepherds in fields as they lay.
Come on, sing along with Bosco
LikeLike
The appeal for me with this blog is the dialogue, friendships, and fellowships. One of the things I’ve discovered is how I can write a 500 word post of mainly just a thought and have all of these great perspectives.
The blog can be trying emotionally with our disagreements, which I’ve learned to better accept, perhaps out of better pray life I have found peace, but I ask forgiveness for misspoken words out of anger. You have become great friends.
LikeLiked by 4 people
Thank you so much.
LikeLiked by 1 person