“A voice was heard in Ramah,
Lamentation and bitter weeping,
Rachel weeping for her children,
Refusing to be comforted for her children,
Because they are no more.”
Little has changed across two millennia in the Middle East; today, as in the time of Christ, mothers weep for their children, killed by tyrants who seek to control what they fear will otherwise destroy them. The feast of Childermas has been celebrated on 28 December in the Latin Church (and a day later in the Eastern Church) since at least the fifth century, and as with all feasts of such antiquity, may go back very much further.
Matthew 2: 16-18 gives us the story of the massacre. Did it actually happen? have no independent testimony, but we do know that Herod’s record was such that it was the sort of thing he did – one of his own wives and three of his own sons were killed on his orders at times when he suspected there were plots to dethrone him; so there is nothing inherently improbably in it. More recent, harrowing examples, from the same region remind us that evil men in power will stop at nothing to retain their position – and that to such men human life is cheap.
Indeed, before the advent of Christianity, human life was generally held cheap. The death rate among new-borns was high, and there would have been few families at the time who did not have the experience of losing a baby, and even a mother, in child-birth. But the massacre of little children was something else – it was seen as barbarous, even in barbarous times. Quite what even barbarous times would make of the modern West’s habit of mass abortions, who can tell? To those without an ideological blindness to it, the practice is appalling, and it is no accident that the abortion industry does not want the details of what goes on inside its clinics more widely spread; few, surely, can read the detail without a feeling of nausea? But such is the state of our ‘civilization’ that now only the Catholic Church holds the line firmly here. The same faith which told the world that even the life of a slave was worth the same as that of an Emperor in the eyes of God, tells an unheeding world that the life of every child in the womb is valued in those same eyes. It holds to a high view of the worth of human life in a world where, increasingly, it is seen as having variable value. The unborn, the handicapped (yes, don’t use the word, but do defend aborting such babies whilst they are in the womb – never forget words are all that matter) and the elderly, especially the elderly who are unwell, all of these lives have a different value to those of the ordinary person of working age upon whom health services can spend a small fortune to keep alive and as fit as possible. All lives matter, but some matter far more than others.
In commemorating the Innocents massacred by Herod, the Church reminds us that human life is created by God, and that God alone should take it. But it also reminds us of the cruelty of our fallen human nature, and the futility of evil. Herod never did catch the child whom the Magi visited, but no matter, he was eventually apprehended by the authorities who persuaded Pilate that this ‘King of the Jews’ was a danger to Roman authority, and Pilate did, belatedly, what Herod had failed to do. A sinless man was sacrificed – and the fears of the authorities assuaged – for a moment and until the next crisis – for rest assured, there will always be another crisis. Yet how many would now know the names of Pilate and Herod were it not for their connection with the story of Jesus of Nazareth?
And we, in our time, what can we do? Simply continue that message that all human life has supreme value in God’s eyes, and do what is in our power to support all Christian organisations which seek to uphold what the Gospels tell us.
The stance for life is fast becoming the stance against life in our world where as you say only words matter. People are actually appalled and angry now when I say I am pro life. It as if I had donned Hawthorne’s scarlet letter.
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is so odd that our societies have accepted this barbarism – or perhaps not, given our fallen nature.
LikeLiked by 2 people
That is a an astute assessment.
LikeLiked by 1 person
One of my favorite Christmas season hymns is the Coventry Carol. You Brits I am sure are familiar, but the hymn…what a reminder of the suffering material world that God chose to become incarnate.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Yes, one of mine too – for the same reason.
LikeLike
On the history of the “slaughter” I’ve heard that in the region that it could have been up to 10 children, which wouldn’t have garnered any other historical notice.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Indeed, especially in light of Josephus’ notice about the big crowd that was gathered into an amphitheatre to be slaughtered at his death.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That would make sense.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your new moons and your appointed feasts my soul hateth: they are a trouble unto me; I am weary to bear them.— God
Do you guys actually have a feast on all these feast days? That’s a lot of turkey and ham and sweet potato pies.
LikeLike
Your version of a feast seems, shall we say, rather materialistic. Perhaps you mistake your stomach for God?
LikeLike
If feast day doesn’t mean having a feast , then I guess there is no big dinner. Ah well. You know, its no secret that I don’t know anything about these big complicated religions. I just love watching them in their natural habitat. Great fun.
LikeLike
Feast days are days for giving extra thanks to God. It’s what those who worship Him like to do – perhaps foreign to those who think worshipping him means putting up a cement dove and bowing to it?
LikeLike
Giving extra thanks. Well, like ive always said….catholics are trying to please an angry god. At least they try. Prots just sit thru a sermon and go home. Both walk out of their services still unsaved. Asking Jesus to come in and sup with you is up to each individual.
LikeLike
Sorry, at what point does thanking God and loving Him equate to being frightened by Him. Are you, perhaps, transferring some of your own issues onto others. Jesus founded a Church, a shame you don’t believe him, but then there is so much Jesus says you have to deny. Can you point me to the passage where Jesus says he will come to each of us individually and there will be no need for a church?
Indeed, can you perhaps clear up something really puzzling in your theology? Why did Jesus have to suffer and die for us if all that was necessary was for him to come a sup with each of us individually? Perhaps write a post explaining?
LikeLike
Ok, thanks for the challenge. Ill write up a post and try to submit it. It will take me awhile. I have to try to go back to sleep now. I have to do some sprucing up on a property because a loan officer is going to take a look at it sometime soon today.
LikeLiked by 1 person
OK – let me know if you any problems – good luck with the property
LikeLike
PS….you equate these feasts with God, but God says he hates these appointed feasts. Just thought id mention that.
LikeLike
Sorry, can you point me to the passage where he says he hates feasts for those who die in his name? Thanks in advance.
LikeLike
Your new moons and your appointed feasts my soul hateth: they are a trouble unto me; I am weary to bear them.— God
God doesn’t mention any feasy day by name. He just says he hates them all. Don’t tell me you want to find an exception?
I don’t envy you. Must be tough being in a religion that does everything God says not to do.
LikeLike
You do know he is talking to the Jews and not Christians there, don’t you? No feast days, really? What do you think the Passover is? What are you on today, Bosco?
LikeLike
God is saying that he repents even of his own feasts and burning incense and sacrifice of animals. He is weary of all of it. It has become a ritual. No one really cares about god. They just perform the ritual. It goes for the Jew and the gentile.
LikeLike
So, in your view, God doesn’t care about those who die for him and doesn’t think they are worth being remembered? An odd view of God.
LikeLike
No, they aren’t worth being rememberd. If they were saved , one doesn’t have to fret about them. They are gone. They cant help you or pray for you. Its idolatry to hold men in esteem for religious purposes. We as humans have enough idolatry in our lives. We don’t need to add more idolatry by belonging to a idolatrous religion. But alas, not everyone who says Lord Lord will enter into heaven. Jesus said only a few will be saved. On top of that….time is running out on the age of grace. Better take a look at your mode of salvation.
LikeLike
So, when on Veterans’ Day or 11 November we remember the soldiers who died to save us, we’re committing idolatry? Really? What are you on today Bosco?
LikeLike
Its early, I haven’t decided which drug I want yet.
I said holding men in esteem for religious purposes is idolatry. Not remembering a loved one who died in war. The CCteaches kids that these dead catholics are up in heaven working on behalf of our salvation….which is a gigantic lie. Then the faithful begin to believe that, such as yourself. Satan throws a stumbling block in the way of you coming to Christ. The devotee thinks hes being aided by the dead catholic and that all is well, when its not.
LikeLike
So, you are happy to remember people who died in a secular war, but think it idolatry to remember those who died for Christ?
LikeLike
Perhaps Bosco forgot the words of St. Paul when we wrote, “One man considers one day more sacred than another; another man considers every day alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind. He who regards one day as special, does so to the Lord.” -Romans 14:5-6 (NIV)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Perhaps good brother Steven is adding meaning to the passage that isn’t there. Perhaps good brother Steven loves to hold men in esteem. Maybe good brother Steven doesn’t know that the special days good brother Paul is referring to are feast days like Passover and harvest and other jewish feast days which none of them had to do with any human. None of them were in celebration of a man. Nice try at besmirching me. Time to get back to burning incense in front of your images of dead catholics.
LikeLike
I simply applied the logic of St. Pauls’ teaching to our times, wherein many religious feasts and observations have accrued within the Church since that time. If a feast day is a remembrance of a specific Christian and reminds us to thank God for their example of holiness then I cannot imagine why that would be objectionable. In Hebrews chapter 11 the author runs through a list of famous believers and their lives of holiness, and calls us to be strengthened by their examples and not lose heart in their current struggles against sin and the world. What the author of Hebrews did in the 11th chapter, is simply adapted by the Church when specific days are earmarked to celebrate the lives of exemplary saints, for the purpose of edification and thanksgiving. I know you’re well aware of this but I provide this information for the sake of those who may be browsing through this conversation, that they may not become confused by your casuistry. I hope your property inspection went well today, Bosco. Take care.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thank you for wishing my endeavors well good brother Steven. I hope all is well with you.
Now lets examine your philosophy. You assume that the CC is a continuation of the Judaic faith, which Jesus was a member. Its my contention that the Catholic religion is not the continuation of the faith laid down by Jesus. Here is my reasoning……God has nothing to do with imagery and idols made by hands. Plus Jesus warned us not to be separate, as in dress. Im holyman and youre not, and my dress shows it. This is what Jesus warned us about. Plus religions have other wacko stuff. Is this what you would rather have than a relation with Christ?
LikeLike
Bosco – again, the number of misconceptions here is astonishing. You certainly hate the caricature of Catholicism you have imbibed from the odd websites you frequent, but that is rather like taking your view of women from pornographic websites.
In the first place, no one with three working brain cells has ever said that Christianity is a continuation of Judaism. You may know some odd Americans caught up in a heresy called Messianic Christianity who think that, but if you could kindly source us a Catholic site which tells us that ‘the CC is a continuation of the Judaic faith’, I’d be amazed. Why do you peddle lies when you say you know Jesus?
You say God has nothing to do with imagery. I assume that you do not think God gave the instructions for the making of the Ark of the Covenant then? we’ve been here so many times. God forbids worshipping images, he does not ban paintings and sculptures; you make the same mistakes as many Muslims.
Finally, we all have a relationship with Christ, which is why you come across of wacko, assuming you are the only one who has, a claim you back with the unbiblical statement that Christ’s sheep know each other, something He never said.
Do you not realise that the only way you can maintain your position is by remaining wilfully ignorant? Well, I have done my best, and when you stand at the Last Judgment you will not be able to say no one told you.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bosco – when do you want your post published?
LikeLike
Bosco – when would you like your post to go out?
LikeLike
Amen. Wonderful video… https://spurgeonwarquotes.wordpress.com/2013/12/30/god-with-us/
LikeLiked by 1 person