From outside, Christianity can look like a set of doctrines, and from inside like a programme for life; both those things are part of it, but they are not the whole. That is one reason we can get frustrated when those outside go on about ‘doctrine’ as though it were the whole, and as though it does not matter; it isn’t, and it does. Similarly, when our fellow Christians, or our priest talks as though the Faith once given were some kind of ‘well-being’ programme which will make us fitter and healthier, we can feel the frustration which comes from seeing something so much bigger and grander, so reduced. Pilate asked ‘what is truth?’ We know that the answer is not a ‘what’, but a ‘who’; Truth is the Person of the Living Christ.
Passiontide reminds us of what that Person underwent for our sake. He was tortured and raised on the Cross to die in agony – for us. For every one of us – and yet so many of us reject Him and regard that sacrifice as nothing to do with us. Some seek to explain it away as not being ‘real’ in the sense that a real human being was scourged, mocked and nailed to the tree only to rise again bodily on the third day. All of that, some say, is a beautiful way of expressing some profound message about the power of redemption and how to live a moral life. That ignores the reality – that messy and awful reality which any sensitive soul might well wish not to dwell upon – of the suffering Servant who really suffers, really dies and really rises. Yet that is at the heart of our faith. On Good Friday we were there with him, and not even the knowledge of the glory to come could turn us from the profound horror of what he suffered. That becomes even worse when we think that it was for us this happened. So we have to glory in that sacrifice, we have to embrace him, and we have to love him.
If we know Christ, then we know that it matters who he is. It is easy enough (which is why it is done so often) to see him as a really good man – but really good men don’t claim to be the Messiah and forgive the sins of others. It is easy to see him as a moral example; but moral men don’t claim to be God. C.S. Lewis got it right all those years ago – Jesus is either who the Church says he is, or he was a madman and our faith is vain.
How shall we, by our own lights, understand such a love? Where is our human experience is there anything which helps us? Only in the language we were taught by Jesus himself. Those of us who are fathers know the lengths we would go to help or save our sons. Well, we are, by adoption, the sons of God, and God went this far to save us. It is not, as St Isaac reminds us, that God could not have saved us in any other way – He is God, and he can do whatever is necessary, it is that nothing else would have sufficed to reveal to us the depth and breadth of that love. When St John tells us that God is love, he means it. That is the whole of it – God is love and reaches out in love to touch us. Once touched, then nothing is the same agian – how could it be?
Interestingly, that is why a priest I knew left one denomination and joined another: he felt that his church was too much about “doctrine” and not enough about doing things.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sadly, Nicholas, that is a typical response in the post VII priesthood and is the overall thinking within the Church: that interior works such as prayer and use of doctrine to amend one’s life and to protect one from the slings and arrows of the world should be tossed away whilst we pick up hammers and nails and dive into programs that involve us as social workers. Many a priest doesn’t even know where his Breviary is anymore . . . probably under an inch of dust.
At one time, these activities were done as an automatic response to the spiritual work we did within ourselves; first and foremost at becoming “children of the light” and not just blindly charging off to do good works for their own sake . . . thinking that secular humanism alone is the fulfillment of the Gospel. If we are not the lights we are supposed to be, how is a bowl of food or a new house going to help the salvation of others? If our corporal works of mercy and our spiritual works of mercy are to have any effect we best make sure that Christ is at the center of our lives before we embark on them. You don’t become a auto mechanic without first learning about the interior workings of an automobile and why you are proposing to fix or replace the things you put your hands to.
I don’t know your friend and maybe this does not apply to him but I have known pastors who would rather not speak of what we need to know in order to deepen our belief in Christ and to transform our lives and imitate Christ in our lives but were gung-ho in creating a ministry for every kind of welfare project imaginable . . . except of course things like praying in front of an abortion mill (too connected to doctrine I suppose).
As C says, we need both. But we can’t succeed in doing the works of God unless we have a conversion of heart and have become sons and daughters of God first and foremost which today seems to be anathema if spoken and taught from the pulpit.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve always thought doctrine should be like clean air – there, but not noticeable because we’re all used to it π
LikeLiked by 1 person
But very noticeable when it is badly polluted perhaps??? π
LikeLiked by 2 people
Indeed π
LikeLiked by 1 person
. . . and when it is a bit thin and you are gasping for breath? π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alas – happens too often nowadays π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aye, much too thin and polluted for most things living. π
LikeLiked by 1 person
We need priests who are drenched in prayer first and foremost, then through their personal relationship with Christ and by his Grace they will be empowered to work through the galvanizing and transforming power of the Holy Spirit. I look for priests who are prayerful men, solidly rooted in Holy Scripture and the Word, who seek God at every turn and are renewed and fed through the Holy Sacrament. Many of the 19 century Anglo-Catholic priests were examples of this, leading prayerful lives but doing incredible work amongst the slums and deprived areas of inner cities. Benedictine wisdom illustrates this well – time for prayer and time for work, otherwise we tend to have, as SF points out, clerics who act as social workers. The danger of this myopic way of living is that ‘the flock’ are not taught, encouraged or shown how to develop a life fed with prayer and consequently the Sunday Mass becomes a ritual to be performed and soon forgotten until the next week, rather than a precious meeting with Christ and a time of renewal – a renewal which needs to be kept nurtured through regular study of spiritual texts and private prayer.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well put OG99.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Spot on – just what we used to have, not least with those old Anglo-Catholic priests.
LikeLike
Has anyone noticed that in the above picture and the picture in the last post, the guy in the pic is doing the same hand sign? Its a known occult hand sign. Just like its counterparts the pine cone and the bent crooked cross and the upside down cross and the all seeing eye.
LikeLike
I’m sure this will be far too much for you to assimilate . . . but do try.
https://iconreader.wordpress.com/2011/05/26/what-does-this-hand-gesture-mean-in-icons/
LikeLiked by 1 person
As an Orthodox, when I make the sign of the cross I hold my right hand in this way and it is customary also to do it three times in recognition of the Holy Trinity. There is a reason for everything and it is this rich symbolism which I enjoy sharing with others who do not know. Many also do not know the reason why the image of a fish was used to indicate a Christian, so that’s another good mission tool too!
LikeLiked by 2 people
It is indeed. There is rich symbolism within traditional forms of Christianity which is lost on many of our members sometimes as well.
LikeLiked by 1 person
“More than this, even if His servants, the Saints, holds their hands in the same way, we are assured of receiving the blessings of God, through the name of Jesus Christ
LikeLike
So, when someone does this hand sign, the blessings flow. so, if one does the hand sign wrong, the blessings wont flow.
LikeLike
It must be a sad place where you are Bosco. You seem dead to imagery, nuance, poetry and symbolism. Is it something to do with being Californian or is it that your education simply has told you nothing about these things? I feel rather sorry for you. Are there no art appreciation courses you could take? No poetry workshops? No art classes?
LikeLike
I do oil on canvas and even sold some on ebay. Music is an are. I play the classic and rock and jazz. My mother got a degree in art from USC. My sister was curator of some museum in DC and is now a doctor of art history and a professor at some university.
Ond old girlfriends mother was catholic as they come. Sweet old dear. She used to sit on her bed and did the pose with the hand sign. Like the article good brother Servus put up, it says the hand sign lets the blessing flow. God must say…. well im not gonna bless you until you do that hand sign.The bible speaks of little else.
LikeLike
Ah, I see you are deliberately misinterpreting what Servus said – not surprising.
LikeLike
Bosco, I have had many blessings from God in my life, all undeserved. Did God make the hand sign as pictured when the blessings flowed? I have no idea because God is, well, you know, not visible.
LikeLike
Good brother Zeke, no need to ask me if the hand sign worked. Ill say that its a fraud and if anyone asks ill tell them its a fraud. But if you feel blessed, what can I say?
LikeLike
Which is, of course, more or less what most here feel about you. You bear no good fruit, and nothing about your writing breathes the spirit of a God who we are told is love. But if you ‘feel’ you are saved, what can the rest of us say?
LikeLike
Those of you here think im coming from an ignorant background. I have to laugh because your background is small and devoid of concrete knowledge. Not one here evokes special relativity or general relativity.
not that that has anything to do with salvation. But is shows that no one backs up his rubric with math. No thinkers here. just talkers. When you go to tell me how stupid I am, talk a pause and think….is Bosco more educated than I? The answer will be yes. Bosco is more educated. But does it matter? No. But does it matter if I call Bosco stupid? No. But it does matter if you are more stupid than bosco. if one isn’t more stupid than Bosco, one is a fool. A fool calls someone stupid who is actually smarter than one.
The wisdom of this world is foolishness with god. But a fool is still a fool
LikeLike
Let us evaluate the evidence for this claim: you cannot spell; you are unable to comprehend what you read or engage in sustained discussion; you are in thrall to a delusion of your own devising, and now, it would seem you are a legend in your own mind. Do, please explain what ‘backs up his rubric with math’ means? My guess is you won’t, as you seldom answer questions. I have no idea what ‘more educated’ means, but if it means one comes across on the Internet as you do, I doubt anyone would be queueing up to receive an education which left them in the likeness of a sad excuse for a follower of Christ.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nobody said you come from an ignorant background, Bosco. But even people from good backgrounds can be ignorant . . . the proof to the contrary would have to be in how you think, express yourself and argue with logic and reason. So far the evidence is not good I’m afraid.
LikeLike
Indeed – and if educated is as educated does … !
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bosco, I did not ask if the hand sign worked. God’s blessings always work, I think we would agree on that. What I suggested to you is that I did not see God’s hand when he blessed me. Did you see his hand when he blessed you? That is my question to you, I think it is clearer now. Did you see with your eyes?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good joke, Bosco! Ha! Ha!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Bosco dear, I found this page which explains the occult significance of hand signals.
http://www.elcosh.org/document/1458/d000068/Excavator%2BHand%2BSignals.html?show_text=1
LikeLiked by 1 person
And “Bosco dear” said Catholics don’t have a sense of humor! π
LikeLiked by 1 person
Only you, Bosco – only you.
LikeLike