Tags
Satan put it into Judas’ heart to betray Jesus. There has been much speculation as to why Judas did it, and even those who have seen him as a necessary part of the story of the Crucifixion and Resurrection; he was, but that does not excuse him, and neither does the fact that Satan put it into his heart. Satan sifts us all constantly. Every day is a trial with him, and every day brings fresh opportunities to imitate Judas in our own way.
As we contemplate the annals of human ingratitude, myopia and pride, Judas takes a special place. Despite being with Jesus for the length of His earthly ministry, Judas appears to have learnt nothing, not only about who he was, but also about what Jesus was teaching. If, as is sometimes implied, it was the use of the expensive ointment which tipped the balance, then we see a not uncommon type in Judas. He knew best. His instinct went towards asceticism, and he had no time for fripperies; he would have been at the forefront of those who demand that the Church sells all the fine artwork which generations of devout souls have given it, in order to feed the poor. Their’s is a world in which man lives by bread alone, and where, once everything which might life the soul up has vanished, life is grim and the poor continue to suffer once all the fine art has gone. Men like this sound as though they mean well, but their actions seldom help those at whom they are aimed, and often do long term harm.
Jessica likes to think that Judas was trying to provoke a revolution, hoping that by arresting Jesus, the authorities would unwittingly light the fuse to a powder keg; if so, it was a pretty spectacular miscalculation.
Thirty pieces of silver was the price paid to Zechariah for his work in watching over a flock of sheep destined for the slaughter. This was the price of a slave according to Exodus. Zechariah took them and threw them to the ‘potter of the Lord’, just as the money Judas took was used to buy the Potter’s field; we have, in other words, a Messianic prophecy in Zechariah 11. Just as Zechariah withdrew his staffs of Favour and Unity from his flock, so too did the Lord from His.
The Son of Man was sold to His enemies for the price of a slave. Judas acted on his own wisdom, saw it had been folly, and then hanged himself. If he had wanted action, what he got did not satisfy him. He had acted by the standards of this world, and Satan had, as he will, found a way in through the chinks in the spiritual armour which are thus created.
Judas set in train the events which, by worldly standards, led to the humiliation of Jesus and his elimination as a threat to the Jewish authorities. By the ninth hour on the Friday afternoon it was, indeed, all over, as the world judges these things. But the world was, as it is on these matters, wrong, and yet it was about to be redeemed – although many of its inhabitants would be as blind as Judas, and continue to be so to this day.
Very well said. And perhaps you would indulge me to say said conservatively, as well.
Especially in the part of the role of the better part of ourselves. I have found at least for myself, the beauty of a proper sanctuary is essential to properly worship God. Asceticism is all very well, as is caring for the poor, but I think it essential to also see what God can accomplish through man.
LikeLike
Thank you Neo. We should worship the Lord in the beauty of holiness.
LikeLike
I completely agree.
LikeLike
You have to wonder what the world would look like if some of these self-proclaimed ascetics had their way; do you suppose they start by giving away all their possessions?
LikeLike
Somehow, I have my doubts. Most seem to be of the “do as I say, not as I do” school. There may well be exceptions but, I haven’t met any.
LikeLike
Quite so – there’s a lot of cheap talk ๐
LikeLike
That there is. ๐
OT: You won, of course.
LikeLike
You know C, the picture I always have in my mind was the rather portly Ted Kennedy walking among the starving people in Africa saying that we must do more and pushing for taxes and money to go to the United Nations to save these poor people. But I did not see Teddy giving up a meal to feed a single soul. Politics is not truly driven by compassion it seems: a photo op and a sound bite is more like it. ๐
LikeLike
This is part of the problem, isn’t it? It is so easy to talk – which is why we get so much of it from politicians, I suppose ๐
LikeLike
It is indeed.
BTW, I ask for prayers for my friend Reid Buckley (brother of Wm. F. Buckley Jr.) who passed away on Monday evening. I will miss our yearly vigil on Good Friday as he and his wife as well as my wife and I usually were the only ones constantly present from 12:00 – 3:00. He was a good and faithful Catholic and I pray for the repose of his soul and peace for his wife, Tassa.
LikeLike
I shall pray for him over the Easter Triduum. May His soul rest in peace.
LikeLike
Spelling correction: His wife’s name is Tasa not Tassa.
Here is an announcement made by National Review Online for those interested: http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/375839/fergus-reid-buckley-rip-jack-fowler
LikeLike
Thank you. I hope others will also join us in praying.
LikeLike
Indeed so and thank you for your prayers.
LikeLike
S.F. sometime in the late 70’s early 80’s I was going with a woman who sent her son to Portsmouth Abbey R.I. I went with her, I think it was, on a “Parents’ Day.” I met a Buckley with a gorgeous blonde wife. I believe that their son was the first to be at that school.
I’ll add your Buckley to my prayer list.
LikeLike
David, that is good of you. I hate to see the thinning of the old guard, faithful Catholics. But hopefully, they ran a good race and will now be praying for us as well.
LikeLike
Indeed C, the example you give of Judas’s response to the use of the expensive spikenard on our Lord’s feet is very reminiscent of the disgust we often hear from those who seem to think that no extravagance should be ‘wasted’ when the money might bring relief to the poor. The Lord did not think so, obviously. In fact, I have often wondered why these same complainers don’t take their complaint to the Lord Himself. After all, as God Whom creates and orders the heavens and the earth, could have eliminated poverty and illness by the utterance of a single word. But He did not. Instead He said that the poor would always be with us. So it seems that God has left the care of the disadvantaged to each of us who are to look out for our neighbors as best we can. And likewise it is still incumbent on us to treat God as God and to appoint the House of God in a way that, to the best of our ability, reflects the dignity and honor that is ‘right and just’ for the Creator of the Universe. For if there is no God worthy of best efforts then there is no reason to serve Him or take our responsibilities to our neighbors seriously. For sure: we do not live by bread alone. Well said C and a good reminder also that practically everyone (Judas, the Jews, the Gentiles, the thousands fed miraculously, the crippled and blind who were cured, those who were raised from the dead etc.) none of these were exactly supporters of our Lord when it came to confronting the authorities. In fact they each, in their own way, fell away and from their initial attraction and abandoned Him as scripture had prophesied. There are many who cry Lord, Lord but do not have the grit to stand up to the responsibilities of this assertion when confronted with adversity.
LikeLike
Thank you. Easy as the temptation to dictate to the Church what it should use its money for, it should be resisted.
LikeLike
Totally agree, especially when one thinks of the many converts who were moved to their core when visiting the old beautiful Churches and felt the grandeur and other-worldliness of the One God – and still do, age after age.
LikeLike
Quite so – love of the Lord has inspired some of the greatest music and other works of art known to mankind.
LikeLike
Yes, like Kumbaya or Shine Jesus Shine for instance. ๐
LikeLike
Suitable hymns for Lent – penitential to listen to ๐
LikeLike
From a catholic point of view, the reason for the decoration of the church is to the Glory of God, present in the Tabernacle.
This is something other religions lack.
LikeLike
Have never been able to resolve Judas issue. It was his pre ordained destiny yet we refuse to absolve him of guilt. Beyond that I don’t understand the use of word betrayal or why betrayal necessary. Surely Jesus was a very public figure and did not hide so why would anyone have to point him out? Certainly the Jewish hierarchy imposed on the Romans to do the arresting and execution.
LikeLike
The Gospel accounts suggest that the Jewish authorities wanted to seize him when he was not amongst crowds where there might have been trouble, so they needed someone to guide them to where he went in the evening.
As for the role of Judas, yes, it is troubling at one level. If Judas had no choice then … well what? We believe God gives us free choice, and therefore it must follow Judas had a choice.
LikeLike
appreciate reply.
LikeLike
My pleasure, Carl – there’s a good one from Servus on Jessica’s post today – have a good Easter.
LikeLike
According to John’s Gospel, the objection to the expensive perfume was less due to an ascetic impulse in Judas and more due to his keen nose for making money. It could have been that same interest in money rather than the Lord which led him to strike a deal for some cash up front. On the other hand, then how do we understand him returning the coins?
(This is TAC, by the way. Seeing the discussion here prompted me to act on an idea I’d been mulling over for a while, namely to start a blog where I present my occasional thoughts/reactions on faith, theology, and the world. It doesn’t have anything interesting yet; I’ve been traveling. My Middle East blog is more about matters which I discuss professionally, and could be shown to professional peers, so the themes of the two blogs are very distinct.)
LikeLike
Good to have you here in your new guise.
Yes, the greed motive is the one often mentioned, and is in many ways the obvious one. I suppose one could see the throwing away of the money as remorse which he expresses in hanging himself.
I shall look forward to your new blog – and wish you a holy and joyful Easter.
LikeLike